Customer Reviews

Customer Reviews

This title company is HANDS DOWN the best! Chris Cioffi with All American Title will hands down take care of everything! With his amazing expertise in title and knowledge he makes the closing process so smooth! Will definitely be using again and will recommend to friends and family!

Whitney Boland

Signature Realty

“I am a loan officer and work with a lot of title companies. I had the pleasure of working with Rebecca at All American Title on a purchase loan. I was impressed with the consistent communication and professionalism throughout the process.”

Jason Williams

Guild Mortgage

Fantastic company to deal with – especially if you’re addressing something at a distance! Very communicative and dedicated to everything progressing smoothly. I would definitely use these folks again!

Deb Scheib


SUPER TITLE COMPANY!!! We had a difficult financed transaction, a non-communicative seller, a total lack of documentation and Carole Castillo managed to bring it all together on time and over a holiday! All American Title is fully staffed by Miracle Workers! They are licensed all over the state, so do not hesitate to call. Amazing.

Amy Hibberd

White Sands Realty Group

Chris and his team did a great job!! Very professional and asked any questions that we had. I would definitely use them in the future.

Pam Pomfret

Plant City Realty

I can’t even begin to explain the level of quality service this company offers! It’s an amazing team and they all work together great!

I had a closing there with a small issue that came up last minute (nothing to do with the title company). The closing agent grabbed an attorney in the same plaza, which they have a good relationship with, and he came running over to help resolve the situation.

They think outside the box and do what is necessary to make sure everyone is happy! What more could you ask of a title company?! GREAT JOB ALL AMERICAN TITLE!

Noli C.


All American Title has done closings for MANY of our borrowers and we at Riverview Mortgage highly recommend them to all of our borrowers! Every closing has gone smoothly and quickly. If you haven’t used All American before you should definitely use them for any of your title needs!

Robyn Engelman

Riverview Mortgage

We just bought in Wimauma. Rebecca Gullick was really fantastic! Kept us informed, was super courteous, professional, and rapidly responsive. I highly recommend her and All American Title. They will NOT disappoint!

Lisa Holthaus


Highly recommend! Closing was smooth and actually early because of holidays, instead of waiting until afterwards which worked best for both seller and buyer. Even with a delay in HOA approval, they got it closed as promised. Great experience which is hard to find in these difficult times. Reasonable closing fees as well.

Brenda Trevino

Signature Realty

Our closing went so smoothly at All American Title. Chris was polite and helpful, and made the process understandable and painless. Would definitely recommend them!

Chris Gagliano


Organized and detailed in every respect with quality upfront communication to help us every step of the way. Highly recommended. Carole Castillo was a pleasure to work with for my closing. She was knowledgeable, informative, and extremely personable.

Charlotte Broadus


I had a Veteran client use this title company for his closing. This was my first time working with them and the experience was ABSOLUTELY WONDERFUL. This company takes a team approach to getting the job done. They were timely and very hospitable. They are COVID-19 conscious and sanitize each room after use.

Tanita Montgomery

Homespire Mortgage

Awesome to work with. Shayla and Jean handled everything amazingly.

Michelle Pearson


All American Title is hands down the best title company I have ever had the pleasure of working with. Their knowledge and customer service is key to contributing to successful timely transactions. Looking forward to many more successful closings with them.

Julie Griffin

Smith & Associates

I can’t say enough good things about All American Title! I am a local Realtor and have personally used them for my own closing. Chris and Carole were both so professional and prompt! I will absolutely refer them in the future. Thanks for another easy closing!

Marilyn Ackerson

Coldwell Banker Dolphin Realty

As a Realtor in the Tampa Bay area for 6 years now, I wanted to give high praise to the professionalism and great response from the team at All American Title. Rebecca Gullick, our title agent was very efficient with all the paperwork needed and response to questions our Buyers had. Hats Off to a great Title Company!

Christie DeNovellis

Mihara & Associates

Painless and organized. Fastest closing I have ever had and very friendly crew working there.

Patrick McGregor


We want to take this opportunity to thank All American Title Company for the efficient way you handled the closing of our home in Brandon. Your staff were very friendly, helpful and professional. The closing went smooth from start to finish and you answered any questions we had to the fullest. We would not hesitate to use All American Title again and would highly recommend them.

Paul and Jeanette Almeida


Get in Touch

Contact Us
Hours of Operation
Brandon: Monday- Friday 9:00am- 4:00pm Southshore and Manatee: Appointment Only

We'll get your title taken care of within 3 days

Instant Title Quote