Voted “Best” of Brandon and Southshore

All American Title

All American Title is a locally owned and operated agency founded in 1995. With close to 30 years in business and over 50 years of combined title insurance experience among our staff, you can expect your closing transaction to be handled with perfection! We have the technology, desire, and integrity to ensure that your expectations are exceeded every time. From first-time homebuyers to investors, residential to large commercial properties, our bilingual, highly skilled staff will guide you through the process of a smooth, stress-free closing!

Contact Us

Our Services

The ways we can help you

Buyers

All American Title, your locally owned and operated title agency for over 30 years, has the tools to help you have a smooth and efficient closing!

Sellers

If you are considering selling your home or investment property on your own, All American Title is your ONE STOP shop!

Commercial

All American Title is not only experienced with residential real estate transactions, we have also closed many of the commercial properties in the greater Tampa Bay area.

Refinance

All American Title will work directly with your lender for a quick and stress-free refinance loan, second mortgage, or home equity line transaction!

Remote Online Notarization

All American Title is licensed to conduct closings for the entire state of Florida with physical locations in the Tampa Bay Area and the ability to conduct online notary closings internationally.

What Our Clients Say

Our experienced staff has handled thousands of closings. If you’re buying, selling, or refinancing, we can help.

“This title company is HANDS DOWN the best! Shayla Payson with All American Title will hands down take care of everything! With his amazing expertise in title and knowledge he makes the closing process so smooth! Will definitely be using again and will recommend to friends and family!”

Whitney Boland

Signature Realty

“I am a loan officer and work with a lot of title companies. I had the pleasure of working with Rebecca at All American Title on a purchase loan. I was impressed with the consistent communication and professionalism throughout the process.”

Jason Williams

Guild Mortgage

“Fantastic company to deal with – especially if you’re addressing something at a distance! Very communicative and dedicated to everything progressing smoothly. I would definitely use these folks again!”

Deb Scheib

Buyer

“All American Title always goes the extra step on making our Real Estate closings a very smooth process. Buyers and sellers walk away with the utmost confidence that their transaction was handled with confidence and professionalism. A big thank you to Shayla for a job well done every time 👊💥‼️”

Mari Colgan

Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate

“I can’t even begin to explain the level of quality service this company offers! It’s an amazing team and they all work together great!

I had a closing there with a small issue that came up last minute (nothing to do with the title company). The closing agent grabbed an attorney in the same plaza, which they have a good relationship with, and he came running over to help resolve the situation.

They think outside the box and do what is necessary to make sure everyone is happy! What more could you ask of a title company?! GREAT JOB ALL AMERICAN TITLE!”

Noli C.

buyer

“The sell of my house went very well with All American Title Company. I was very pleased and would definitely recommend their services for all your needs! Thank you!”

Mika Talk

Seller

Our Team

Our experienced staff has handled thousands of closings. If you’re buying, selling, or refinancing, we can help.

Susan Luther

Founder

Rebecca Gullick

Company President, Licensed Title Agent & Certified Land Closer

Shayla Payson

Office Manager & Licensed Title Agent

Jean Garcia

Licensed Title Agent

Jordan Fleck

Marketing Director

About Us

All American Title’s mission is to be the leading title and real estate settlement service provider by serving our customers in a professional, efficient manner with a friendly and personal touch. With continuous resource development, technological innovation, teamwork, and communication, we strive to deliver unparalleled title service and customer satisfaction. We pride ourselves on our reliability, friendliness, and our strong values of integrity, competency, and professionalism.

“Always do right. This will gratify some people and astonish the rest.” - Mark Twain