Employee Bios


Susan Luther:

Sue is the owner and founder of All American Title, which she started in March of 1995. Sue has worked in the title industry since 1977 and prides herself in knowing every single aspect and position in All American Title. Sue has worked in various states in this industry and is responsible for handling the closings of many developments and high liability, commercial transactions, some over $50,000,000.00! She is actively involved in the community, being a part of many local associations, as well as state and national title insurance associations. Sue is very proud in knowing that All American Title has helped thousands of families achieve the All-American dream of home ownership and knowing that All American Title will be here for them in the future! Sue loves the water, so her weekends are spent on the boat, by the pool, or at the beach with her two dogs, her husband, and her grandkids whenever possible.


Rebecca Gullick:

Rebecca has been a member of the All American Title family since 2003. She graduated from the University of South Florida (Go Bulls!) with a Business Economics degree. Rebecca is currently a Licensed Title Agent and Office Manager. She has worked her way through the company, holding many positions including closing, accounting, post-closing, receptionist, processing, and warehousing. Rebecca is very knowledgeable about title insurance issues and will make sure that all customers have a smooth and successful closing. In her spare time, Rebecca enjoys spending time with her husband, son, and daughter, attending USF football games, amusement parks, and traveling.


Monica Watkins:

Monica joined the All American Title family in August of 2014. She started in the title industry in May of 1999 and has been a Licensed Closing Agent since March of 2006. Monica has a vast array of knowledge in all aspects of the title industry. She prides herself in being a team player and helping customers have a successful closing. In her spare time, Monica enjoys spending time with her family, cooking, and watching her daughter dance. She also loves spending time with her corgi and sheltie.


Sasha Batres:

Sasha is a licensed title agent with over 13 years of title industry experience. She joined the All American Title family in June of 2015. Sasha has a wide array of industry knowledge, due in part to her several years spent closing REO transactions nationwide. Sasha enjoys meeting all of her customers, and prides herself on her willingness to go above and beyond for each and every one of them. If she isn’t using her free time to travel to her home state of Rhode Island, Sasha enjoys spending her free time reading, fishing, and exploring the Tampa Bay area with her husband and stepdaughter.


Shayla Payson:

Shayla came to All American Title as a newbie to the title world, but that hasn’t hindered her at all! Being eager to learn and grow, she quickly became our newest Closing Agent! Shayla is a great team player, loves to help our customers have a successful closing, and is rapidly becoming extremely knowledgeable in many aspects of title. Shayla lives in Plant City and enjoys spending time with her family, friends, and doing most any outdoor activity, especially attending her home-town Strawberry Festival every year.


Skylar Kelly:

Skylar is the newest addition to our team.  She has been in the title industry since 2014, beginning as a receptionist.  She quickly   grew a strong interest and passion for title and was promoted to processing and then eventually became a closer.  Skylar was born and raised in Riverview, Florida.  She has two beautiful girls who she spends ALL of her time with when she is not working.  Skylar prides herself on her career and the time she spends with her beloved family.


Chris Cioffi:

Chris joined All American Title in March, 2018 taking on a position in Business Development. He recently graduated from the University of South Florida with a Bachelor’s degree in Marketing. He is eager to learn all he can about the title insurance industry and translate that into smooth closings for all involved! In his spare time, Chris coaches wrestling at Spoto High School, is training for his first half marathon, and watches Jeopardy! with his father.


Holly Hollenbeck:

Holly is a Floridian through-and-through, born at St. Joseph’s Hospital in Tampa.  She is new to the title industry and is eager to learn and grow with All American Title.  She is a past-president of the Success Express BNI chapter and has extensive experience in marketing, promotions, sales, and networking.  She enjoys spending time with her two children, Jacob and Caleb, attending local art and food festivals, amusement parks, and canvas painting in her spare time.


Alexis Chesser:

Alexis is one of our newest additions to the team and is also new to the title world. She is currently our front desk receptionist in the Brandon office. Alexis has a bubbly personality to welcome our customers and make them feel at home. She strives to learn as much as she can about our industry and hopes to move up with the company in the future. Alexis lives in Mulberry and enjoys spending time with her husband and her adopted black lab on their boat.


Carole Castillo:

Carole is a true Floridian, born and raised in Tampa. She started with All American Title in August, 2017, coming to us with over 8 years in Residential Property Management experience. Carole is enjoying learning a new side of real estate in the title insurance industry. She takes pride in being a team player and learning new things. In her spare time, Carole enjoys spoiling her two nephews and spending time with family and friends. She loves any outdoor activities including the beach, summer time concerts, and exploring new restaurants and festivals to entertain the foodie that she is! “Always be the type of friend you would want to have.”